As a tobacco retailer, you are likely aware of the ever-changing landscape of the tobacco industry and the regulatory challenges it poses. Over the years, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has been striving to reduce tobacco-related diseases and deaths among smokers and non-smokers alike, particularly by targeting underage tobacco use. However, recent developments, especially the rise of vaping, have introduced new complexities that the FDA is struggling to address effectively. Additionally, the emergence of nicotine-free flavored combustible non-tobacco products presents a new set of challenges for the regulatory agency.

The Vaping Phenomenon

While the FDA’s efforts to reduce cigarette use were showing promising results, the introduction of vaping disrupted the progress. Vape brands saw a significant spike in usage, especially among younger age groups. The National Youth Tobacco Survey revealed that a staggering 11.5% of 12- to 17-year-olds were using vape products, nearly triple the per-capita use by adults.

One of the unintended consequences of the FDA’s approach was that it inadvertently led people to believe that vaping was safer, even though it is equally addictive. This perception opened up opportunities for alternative nicotine products like pouches and lozenges, which were considered less harmful. However, without appealing flavors, these products failed to gain traction, leaving cigarettes as the default choice.

Regulatory Challenges with New Tobacco Products

The situation became even more complex when premium imported cigars and hemp cigarettes entered the market. The FDA found that their existing regulatory framework did not adequately address these products, leaving the agency in a state of uncertainty. The lack of coherent regulations for hemp cigarettes and the limited scope of current rules for cannabidiol (CBD) only added to the confusion.

FDA’s Attempted Ban on Flavored Tobacco

In 2022, the FDA proposed bans on menthol tobacco cigarettes and flavored tobacco cigars in retail stores, with the aim of reducing cigarette consumption by 25%, particularly among African Americans who predominantly smoke menthol. However, this move attracted lawsuits and debates over the actual impact of the ban, given that the percentage of underage smokers using menthol cigarettes was relatively low.

The Rise of Nicotine-Free Flavored Non-Tobacco Products

Amidst the regulatory challenges and bans on tobacco products, a new trend is emerging – nicotine-free flavored combustible non-tobacco products. These products do not contain nicotine or tobacco and are not currently subject to FDA rulemaking. Instead of ending flavored smoking products, this development is offering consumers a range of non-tobacco, nicotine-free alternatives with various enjoyable flavors.

These new products, such as nicotine-free menthols and other flavored options, are already gaining popularity. Companies are using botanical blends, hemp, or CBD-infused herbals to create enticing smoking alternatives. Given the void left by the FDA’s bans, these products are likely to find ample space on retail shelves.

Implications for Tobacco Retailers

As a tobacco retailer, it is crucial to keep a close eye on these emerging trends. Nicotine-free, non-tobacco smoking products fall outside the FDA’s regulatory authority, which may open up new opportunities for retailers. However, it is essential to approach these products with caution, as their appeal and potential health risks are still relatively unknown.

In conclusion, the FDA is facing numerous challenges in its mission to combat tobacco-related health issues, especially with the rise of vaping and the introduction of new nicotine-free, non-tobacco smoking products. While the agency has made progress in reducing cigarette consumption, the emergence of alternative products is reshaping the tobacco market. As a tobacco retailer, staying informed about these developments and exercising due diligence in choosing products to sell will be vital in navigating the changing landscape of the tobacco industry.

We, at, are here to assist retailers by providing the largest selection of point of sale tobacco fixtures and cigarette displays, and offering retailers the fixtures and point of sale products that they need to keep cigarette, tobacco and smokeless sales a viable and profitable category.

Visit our website to view a full range of tobacco fixtures and cigarette displays. With the exception of custom units, all pricing is disclosed on our website and online ordering is very simple. Call us and we’ll provide you with immediate pricing for all custom units.

(866) 630-2100

Jim Richards

Jim Richards is President of TheCstoreEstore, the leading online distributor of point of sale cigarette racks, tobacco fixtures and cigarette display cabinets and the exclusive manufacturer of M-Series Overhead Cigarette Racks.